Compatibility Notes for rsyslog v4
Written by Rainer Gerhards (2009-07-15)
The changes introduced in rsyslog v4 are numerous, but not very intrusive. This document describes things to keep in mind when moving from v3 to v4. It does not list enhancements nor does it talk about compatibility concerns introduced by v3 (for this, see the rsyslog v3 compatibility notes).
With v3 and below, rsyslog used the traditional HUP behaviour. That meant that all output files are closed and the configuration file is re-read and the new configuration applied.
With a program as simple and static as sysklogd, this was not much of an issue. The most important config settings (like udp reception) of a traditional syslogd can not be modified via the configuration file. So a config file reload only meant setting up a new set of filters. It also didn't account as problem that while doing so messages may be lost - without any threading and queuing model, a traditional syslogd will potentially always loose messages, so it is irrelevant if this happens, too, during the short config re-read phase.
In rsyslog, things are quite different: the program is more or less a framework into which loadable modules are loaded as needed for a particular configuration. The software that will acutally be running is taylored via the config file. Thus, a re-read of the config file requires a full, very heavy restart, because the software acutally running with the new config can be totally different from what ran with the old config.
Consequently, the traditional HUP is a very heavy operation and may even cause some data loss because queues must be shut down, listeners stopped and so on. Some of these operations (depending on their configuration) involve intentional message loss. The operation also takes up a lot of system resources and needs quite some time (maybe seconds) to be completed. During this restart period, the syslog subsytem is not fully available.
From the software developer's point of view, the full restart done by a HUP is rather complex, especially if user-timeout limits set on action completion are taken into consideration (for those in the know: at the extreme ends this means we need to cancel threads as a last resort, but than we need to make sure that such cancellation does not happen at points where it would be fatal for a restart). A regular restart, where the process is actually terminated, is much less complex, because the operating system does a full cleanup after process termination, so rsyslogd does not need to take care for exotic cleanup cases and leave that to the OS. In the end result, restart-type HUPs clutter the code, increase complexity (read: add bugs) and cost performance.
On the contrary, a HUP is typically needed for log rotation, and the real desire is to close files. This is a non-disruptive and very lightweigth operation.
Many people have said that they are used to HUP the syslogd to apply configuration changes. This is true, but it is questionable if that really justifies all the cost that comes with it. After all, it is the difference between typing
$ kill -HUP `cat /var/run/rsyslogd.pid`versus
$ /etc/init.d/rsyslog restartSemantically, both is mostly the same thing. The only difference is that with the restart command rsyslogd can spit config error message to stderr, so that the user is able to see any problems and fix them. With a HUP, we do not have access to stderr and thus can log error messages only to their configured destinations; exprience tells that most users will never find them there. What, by the way, is another strong argument against restarting rsyslogd by HUPing it.
So a restart via HUP is not strictly necessary and most other deamons require that a restart command is typed in if a restart is required.
Rsyslog will follow this paradigm in the next versions, resulting in many benefits. In v4, we provide some support for the old-style semantics. We introduced a setting $HUPisRestart which may be set to "on" (tradional, heavy operation) or "off" (new, lightweight "file close only" operation). The initial versions had the default set to traditional behavior, but starting with 4.5.1 we are now using the new behavior as the default.
Most importantly, this may break some scripts, but my sincere belief is that there are very few scripts that automatically change rsyslog's config and then do a HUP to reload it. Anyhow, if you have some of these, it may be a good idea to change them now instead of turning restart-type HUPs on. Other than that, one mainly needs to change the habit of how to restart rsyslog after a configuration change.
Please note that restart-type HUP is depricated and will go away in rsyslog v5. So it is a good idea to become ready for the new version now and also enjoy some of the benefits of the "real restart", like the better error-reporting capability.
Note that code complexity reduction (and thus performance improvement) needs the restart-type HUP code to be removed, so these changes can (and will) only happen in version 5.
outchannelsNote: as always documented, outchannels are an experimental feature that may be removed and/or changed in the future. There is one concrete change done starting with 4.6.7: let's assume an outchannel "mychannel" was defined. Then, this channel could be used inside an
*.* $mychannelThis is still supported and will remain to be supported in v4. However, there is a new variant which explicitely tells this is to be handled by omfile. This new syntax is as follows:
*.* :omfile:$mychannelNote that future versions, specifically starting with v6, the older syntax is no longer supported. So users are strongly advised to switch to the new syntax. As an aid to the conversion process, rsyslog 4.7.4 and above issue a warning message if the old-style directive is seen -- but still accept the old syntax without any problems.